1999
Anna McClintic
Orleans, Ind. |
| 
2000
Alaina Smith
Greenwood, Ind. |
| 
2001
Brianne Camenisch
Lanesville, Ind. |
|
2003
Kari Schultz
Winamac, Ind.
| 
2004
Chris Haley
Burrows, Ind. | 
2005
Corey Rost
Wheatfield, Ind. |
2006
Vanessa Sizemore
Pierceton, Ind.
| 
2007
Bethany Overdorf
Noblesville, Ind.
| 
2008
Lorraine Lorenz
Peru, Ind. |