1999
Joy Hammond
Memphis, Ind. |
| 
2000
Justin Hagerman
Ligonier, Ind. |
| 
2001
Audrey Carie
Vincennes, Ind. |
2003
Alison Cooper
Birdseye, Ind.
| 
2004
Gerritt Schuitema
DeMotte, Ind. | 
2005
Kyle Miller
Peru, Ind. |
2006
Corey Rost
Wheatfield, Ind.
| 
2007
Sam Miller
Paoli, Ind.
| 
2008*
Evelyn Walker
Sunman, Ind. |